#661 (Long post)
Introduction: A Spark of Willpower
Thirty-five + years ago, I made a decision that changed my life in a matter of minutes: I quit smoking in minutes, end of the story. No patches, no gradual tapering—just a firm resolve to stop. It wasn’t easy, but that moment of willpower felt like a superpower. Similarly, for years, I’ve woken up at 3 a.m. to start my day, not because it’s fun, but because I decided it’s who I am. These aren’t just anecdotes; they’re evidence of a trait I’ve come to see as essential: willpower.
Life is a whirlwind of changes, uncertainties, and adversities. Willpower is often the rudder that helps us steer through the storm—whether it’s changing course, staying grounded, or making tough, practical decisions. But is willpower the ultimate key to a complete life, or is there more to the story? This question hit me this morning while reading the Economist’s latest Banyan column, which described how Indian TV channels have been whipping viewers into a frenzy over recent military escalations. As someone who hasn’t watched TV—not even news, sports, or live broadcasts—for 12 years, I felt a quiet pride in my ability to opt out. It resonated with my sense of willpower. Yet, I’ve also been hearing a counterargument: forming habits, not relying on willpower, is the real secret to staying on course. So, let’s dive deep into willpower—its strengths, its limits, and what else we need to live intentionally.
The Case for Willpower: A Force of Transformation
Willpower is the ability to make conscious decisions and stick to them, even when it’s hard. It’s the mental muscle that powers us through moments of temptation, fear, or inertia. Psychologists like Roy Baumeister describe it as a finite resource, akin to energy in a battery, which we can deplete but also strengthen with practice. For me, willpower has been a game-changer in several ways:
Overcoming Adversity: Quitting smoking 35 years (1989) ago wasn’t just about saying no to a cigarette; it was about reclaiming control over my health and future. (I wonder If Lalitha would have said yes, a year later if I was a smoker !!) That single act of will rippled into other areas of my life, proving I could tackle big challenges.
Navigating Uncertainty: Life’s unpredictability demands quick, decisive action. Whether it’s choosing to avoid the sensationalism of TV news or sticking to a 3 a.m. wake-up routine, willpower helps me align my actions with my values.
Building Identity: Willpower shapes who we are. My decision to ditch TV for 12 years wasn’t just about avoiding noise; it was a deliberate choice to prioritize clarity and focus. Each act of will reinforces the person I want to be.
The Economist’s Banyan column highlighted how Indian TV channels have been sensationalizing military escalations, pulling viewers into a cycle of emotional manipulation. Resisting that pull takes willpower—a conscious choice to step away from the “jolly ride” of sensationalism and seek truth elsewhere (like reading the Economist instead! - or whatever!! ). In a world designed to hijack our attention, willpower is a shield, letting us choose what deserves our focus.
The Limits of Willpower: When It’s Not Enough
But willpower isn’t a magic bullet. Relying on it alone can be like trying to sprint a marathon. Research, like Baumeister’s work on ego depletion, shows that willpower wanes under stress, fatigue, or decision overload. If I had to summon the same grit every day to avoid smoking or wake up at 3 a.m., I’d burn out. This is where the critics of willpower have a point: it’s not always sustainable.
I’ve noticed this in my own life. While quitting smoking was a dramatic act of will, staying smoke-free for decades wasn’t about white-knuckling it every day. It became second nature—a new normal. Similarly, my TV-free lifestyle isn’t a daily battle; it’s just how I live now. This shift from willpower to automaticity raises a question: if willpower gets us started, what keeps us going?
Habits: The Unsung Heroes of Consistency
Enter habits—the quiet, powerful force that takes over when willpower fades. Habits are behaviors we perform automatically, with minimal conscious effort. It is the interesection of Knowledge, Desire, Skills. As Charles Duhigg explains in The Power of Habit, habits follow a loop: cue, routine, reward. Over time, these loops become wired into our brains, making actions feel effortless. I was struck by this idea when I heard psychologist Wendy Wood on a podcast a few years back, discussing her book Good Habits, Bad Habits. Wood argues that willpower is overrated because it’s effortful and unreliable, especially under stress. Instead, she says, habits drive about 40% of our daily actions. By shaping our environment—like keeping cigarettes out of reach or curating a newsstand instead of a TV—we make good behaviors automatic. My smoking cessation and TV-free life are perfect examples: what started as willful acts became habits, wired into my identity through years of repetition.
For example, my 3 a.m. wake-up started as a willful act, but now it’s a habit. The cue (my mental alarm like Jack Reacher's), routine (getting out of bed after thanksgiving prayer to be alive), and reward (a quiet, productive morning until 5am) are so ingrained that I rarely need to “decide” to do it. Similarly, avoiding TV isn’t a daily struggle; it’s a lifestyle shaped by years of consistent choices. Habits are like autopilot, keeping us on course without draining our mental battery.
The debate about willpower versus habits isn’t really a contest—both are essential, but they serve different roles:
Willpower is the spark that ignites change, like deciding to quit smoking or skip TV news.
Habits are the engine that sustains change, turning one-time decisions into second nature.
To build habits that stick, research like Wood’s suggests a few strategies:
Start Small: James Clear, author of Atomic Habits, recommends tiny changes, like reading one page a day, to build momentum.
Stack Habits: Pair a new habit with an existing one. For instance, I meditate right after my 3 a.m. black coffee (with Cinamon sprinkled), leveraging the morning routine as a cue. 90 Minutes flies..!! (Flow as they call!). Same is with my 20,000+ steps a day, thanks to 10s of American / British Podcasts.!! (Indian??? ahhaaaaaa Sorry, No way!).
Focus on Identity: Instead of aiming to “exercise more,” adopt the identity of “someone who moves daily.” My TV-free life works because I see myself as someone who values clarity over noise.
Willpower and Habits in Harmony
The interplay between willpower and habits is where the magic happens. Willpower gets you through the door; habits keep you in the room. My smoking cessation began with a burst of will, but it was the habit of living smoke-free that made it permanent. My TV-free streak started with a conscious rejection of sensationalism, but it’s the habit of seeking out thoughtful sources (like the Economist, WSJ, FT, Breitbart) that keeps me grounded.
This synergy is critical because life isn’t static. New challenges—like the media frenzy described in the Banyan column—require fresh acts of willpower to resist or adapt. But once you’ve made a choice, habits can lock it in. For instance, if you decide to avoid sensational news, you might use willpower to mute TV channels initially, but over time, curating a habit of reading reliable sources becomes second nature.
Is Willpower Overrated?
So, is willpower a positive trait or not a big deal? It’s both. Willpower is a vital tool for initiating change and navigating life’s uncertainties, as my own experiences show. Without it, I wouldn’t have quit smoking, built a 3 a.m. routine, or resisted the pull of TV for 12 years. It’s a cornerstone of personal growth and resilience.
But it’s not the whole story. Over-relying on willpower is like expecting a single muscle to carry you through life—it’ll tire out. Habits, systems, and identity-based thinking are what make change sustainable. Wendy Wood’s research drives this home: by designing our environments and routines, we reduce the need for willpower. The recent chatter I’ve heard about habits being more critical than willpower isn’t wrong; it’s just half the equation. Willpower and habits are partners, not rivals.
Conclusion: Crafting a Life of Intention
As I reflect on my journey—I see willpower as the spark that lit the fire and habits as the fuel that keeps it burning. For anyone looking to navigate change or build a meaningful life, my advice is simple: lean on willpower to start, but don’t stop there. Build habits that make your choices second nature. See yourself as the person you want to be, whether it’s someone who lives smoke-free, wakes up early, or seeks truth over noise. Together, willpower and habits don’t just help you stay on course—they help you become the person you’re meant to be.
What’s your story of willpower or habits? I’d love to hear how you’ve navigated life’s changes. For me, it’s an ongoing journey—one I’m proud to share through this blog.
Karthik
16/5/25 9am.